Wednesday, 18 November 2026

It gets better: "La Bola Negra"


Was this the year that marked a decisive seachange in Spanish cinema? This summer's Cannes saw the launch of the latest autofiction by Pedro Almodóvar
, eminence grise of Iberian film (and queer-leaning Iberian film in particular). Yet the excessively convoluted Bitter Christmas subsequently came and went without trace; and the Cannes Best Director prize instead went to La Bola Negra, a period epic produced by Almodóvar for the emergent imagemakers known as Los Javis (being writer-directors Javier Ambrossi and Javier Calvo). Where their producer broke through by merging cinema with the punk scene from which he emerged, the Javis reveal an altogether more literary bent: for their breakout film, they've expanded an unfinished Federico García Lorca text into a triptych not unlike 2002's The Hours, composed of three subtly intertwining portraits of gay men. In 1932, we meet Carlos (Milo Quifes), a young gambler from an upper-class family, whose sexuality prevents him from obtaining entry into an exclusive members' club. (Hence the black ball of the title.) In 1937, we encounter Sebastián (played by the musician Guitarricadelafuente), a proud young bugle boy with the Francoist forces - and a mildly distracting resemblance to Stephen Mangan - who undergoes a personal epiphany upon being sent to guard the hunkiest prisoner in the Nationalist Army hospital: a fearless Republican resistance fighter (Miguel Bernardeau) with Christ-like stigmata he reportedly obtained from "walking towards the bombs". And in 2017, we cross paths with Alberto (Carlos González), a disaffected playwright - with a distracting resemblance to Matt Berry; the Oscar-night spoof practically films itself at this point - whose certainties are shaken upon hearing the news his maternal grandfather has died. All three are callow, varyingly conservative gay men, struggling to express themselves, desperate to fit in; what we see with the benefit of historical distance, however, is that they tessellate closely with one another - rather too well, indeed, for the movie's first half.

Because for something like 70 or 80 of its 160 minutes, La Bola Negra appears to be telling much the same story in different times and places: that of shruggingly indifferent protagonists being gradually awakened to something. (Much too late, in at least one of these cases.) These characters are initially defined by their passivity. Carlos, adrift in a world of privilege, is a mopey dreamer; Sebastián a swooner, falling for any strongman who enters his field of vision; Alberto a heavy-set sadsack (yes, he's a bottom) who reluctantly assumes the role of intergenerational messenger. For a long while - and this may well seem a dramatic liability for some - they are the least interesting characters in their own stories, upstaged by those around them. The unquestioning Sebastián is reduced to gazing in wonder at the freedom fighter, who goes by the mythically sexy name of Rafael Rodríguez Rapún; Carlos is briefly knocked offscreen by a mystic old woman he encounters in a bar (Mona Martínez); while the trudging Alberto appears far less compelling than his coke-addled mother (Almodóvar veteran Lola Duenas) whose personal and domestic dishevelment reflects a tangled and unruly family history. Where Almodóvar typically centres such oddballs and outsiders, characters whose lives extend far beyond the frame, Los Javis' protagonists are much more insular and self-contained: squares, nerds and dullards. For a long while, I wondered why anybody would have thought to make a film about the three dullest gay men in history - and the Javis themselves seemed to acknowledge my suspicions by consciously overcompensating, whether by onscreen firework display, a cabaret overseen by a plucked Penélope Cruz (doing a messier, funnier Cotillard-as-Piaf routine) or simply by having the camera wander off during one hospital-ward heart-to-heart between Sebastián and Rafael Rodríguez Rapún (rrrrrrrr) to observe the buff young men jostling in the corridors outside. (And you think: is even the camera getting bored?) It's not impossible reticent gay viewers will see themselves in here somewhere, but after a while, the character studies start to resemble directorial self-portraits, such is the flat timidity of the filmmaking. The film's passionless sex scenes are shot at a respectful distance, with towels and sheets over key areas; Los Javis appear happier visualising sublimated desire, whether an anguished Sebastián retreating to a bathroom to blow his own trumpet or a pent-up Carlos banging his brains out on a piano keyboard. Historically, La Bola Negra shows us, being gay has always been somewhat frustrating; still, take one look at the poster for Julio Medem's Sex & Lucía prominently displayed on the wall of Alberto's flat, and you can't help but consider how far backwards the movies have slid in their depiction of love and lust.

La Bola Negra does, however, have one sort-of virtue and one saving grace, neither of them negligible. The sort-of virtue is that this is no Emilia Pérez, even if it often seems as though Los Javis have oversteered towards an opposite extreme, away from misdirected passion and towards an elegant fussiness. There is a lot of elegance here, not least in the Javis' group tableaux: a village gathering in heady anticipation of cheering Franco's boys, skinnydipping soldiers lined up on a beach. (It is as tasteful as the Nationalist mural we see going up on the hospital's walls.) The Javis are good on the bigger picture, that much becomes clear, but what's gone missing is Almodóvar's gift for vividly prickly, detailed portraiture - for finding the seductive eccentricity and idiosyncrasy - and the old punk's desire to transgress, to push beyond the movie centreground in such a way that actively engages and tests the audience. The shadow of Almodóvar looms large over Los Javis, as surely as Alberto's family is haunted by the spectres of the Civil War, and watching La Bola Negra is not unlike watching the Spanish cinema of your youth being remodelled by new, more circumspect owners. Out go the sharp edges, suggestive loose ends, the potent pangs of emotion; out goes lived experience, replaced by literary theory; out, too, the vibrant colours, replaced by a more generic, beigey gold. The movie is finely felt and sensitive, such that Cruz's cabaret act can open with an aside on the furniture and porcelain sharing the stage with her. (Backstage, she compares a former lover's hands to a Bronzino painting: the film's good taste is rarely in question, which hasn't always been the case with Almodóvar.) But it often seems too finely felt to be as dramatically forceful as it might have been, and so sensitive it's at risk of seeming stifled. Its saving grace, in the end, is good old-fashioned structure: it strikes me as significant that Los Javis come from TV - their acclaimed miniseries La mesías/The Messiah is presently streaming on MUBI - and thereby know their way around an A-B-and-C plot. (And, believe me, Carlos's story is none more C-plot: a theatrical stub girded by authorial speculation.) Belatedly, everything comes together; retrospectively, we gather these characters were blanks specifically created to fulfil some higher narrative purpose (whispered addendum: where Almodóvar would have afforded them all some past); and the plot (and, in fairness, the frame) does open up. There is value in queering the Lean-like period epic, even if it feels intrinsically perverse that this European arthouse equivalent emerges as far more artistically conservative than The Hours, a feminist text engineered by men working close to the heart of Hollywood. If La Bola Negra succeeds in carrying its present momentum deep into awards season, it'll be for one reason: it does get better - and at least slightly bolder - the longer it goes on.

La Bola Negra is now showing in selected cinemas.

No comments:

Post a Comment