We are, after all, back within touching distance of that old social realist standby, the kitchen sink. (During one family meal, the silences are made more awkward still by the sound of a sporadically dripping tap.) Leigh's eye for the humdrum yet revealing is as sharp as ever. Hard Truths is bookended by scenes in which Pansy's dumbstruck plumber husband Curtley (David Webber) removes first a radiator, then a bath from a client's house, a process I don't think I've seen in a movie before; when Pansy pauses her afternoon cleaning to unwind on the sofa, it's to watch one of those A Place in the Sun-type schedule fillers, rubbing in what she cannot afford and will likely never have. No wonder everyone's unhappy nowadays; and as the media drifts further off into fantasyland, intoxicating their audience with aspirational escapism, there's something both sobering and admirable about Leigh's stubborn allegiance to realism as a form. Some of the behaviour we'll be watching here has been heightened and accentuated, the better to fit the big screen, but a far higher percentage of Hard Truths suggests a ready cognisance of how life now is for a lot of British people. A central tenet of Leigh's method has been that the actors compile a list of folks they know, and crucially what they're like; that technique pays off here in extraordinary ways.
For a while, you may fear - much as some worried about Johnny in Naked - that Pansy is going to be too much, so relentless is she in her axegrinding, yet even in the midst of her loudest wails of despair, she remains recognisable as a very British type: the person who is woefully unhappy about their life, yet so terrified of making even small changes to their narrow routine that all that anxious, negative energy gets projected outwards onto anybody unfortunate enough to be in the vicinity. She's constantly being triggered; nothing's good enough or clean enough, and even the sight of a happy couple contemplating a sofa purchase serves to remind her of her own shortcomings. Some viewers have chosen to interpret this as another of the downcast Leigh's occasional self-portraits, altogether less flattering than Tim Spall's Turner - but, really, here but for the grace of God and a few lucky breaks go any of us. In the real world, such grousing can be funny to observe for a while, as indeed it is here; whether babies, dogs, close family or complete strangers, they all get it in the neck. Over the long haul, though, it's potentially exhausting and crushing. Though Pansy reacts to the presence of a fox in her back garden in much the same shrieking way a Sun reader might to just the idea of immigrants, it's not quite as simple as that she represents Brexit in human form. But she does feel like an embodiment of the many sicknesses and neuroses that have plagued this country in recent times: the isolationism and lack of long-term vision, the insecurity coupled to a hairtrigger temper, the constant lashing out. (And it's not even as if she's on social media.) Everything is everybody else's fault, because it's too painful to look inwards for long. A dentist, in passing, compliments Pansy on the cleanliness of her teeth, but it's the sharp end of our heroine's tongue she has to worry about, and there is no Mr. Muscle for the human heart; it takes an inordinate amount of scrubbing to remove the build-up of pain, disappointment and resentment, and good luck getting on a therapist's waiting list at this moment in time.
This was Leigh's final collaboration with the cinematographer Dick Pope before the latter's death last year, and after the dense period detail of Mr. Turner and Peterloo, Hard Truths marks a return to the look of those films the pair fashioned with TV money through the 1980s and 1990s. Leigh has never been one for undue adornment; he doesn't want anything to obscure these performances and what they represent. (The characters are multilayered, even if the worlds they inhabit are somewhat austere - or have fallen subject to austerity.) Yet the new film is properly widescreen - at one point catching five variably content folks seated side-by-side, like notes on a descending scale - and Leigh and Pope smartly use summer sunshine to offset the aggro, our sense there's a brouhaha waiting to happen in every car park and supermarket queue. We always feel this Britain - even this London - would be very pretty between May and September, if only we could keep the people out of sight. Every frame is similarly suffused with that wisdom born of careful observation. Pansy has a sister, Chantelle (Michele Austin), a hairdresser and a people person, which gives the film somewhere else to go whenever its protagonist becomes unbearable: her household, with its two energised twentysomething daughters (Ani Nelson and Sophia Brown), is all colour, life, enthusiastic dishevelment. One of the girls slings her feet up on the sofa, which Pansy - endlessly berating her morose son Moses (Tuwaine Barrett) - simply wouldn't tolerate. These cutaways at first seem a jolting break from the depressive norm - who are these healthily adjusted people, and what on earth are they doing in the same film/country/universe as a black cloud such as Pansy? - but they cast new light on our heroine's plight: Chantelle's clan have developed coping strategies - for setbacks in life, work and love - which the terse, uptight and eternally defensive Pansy hasn't. Visually, too, the contrast between the two households keeps the film lithe and lively: whenever we tire of seeing a woman hunkering down in a dismal rut, Leigh can cut to one of the girls on an afternoon run and keep things moving. What Leigh appears to have learnt from his recent experiences is the importance of flexibility, particularly as one gets older: looking beyond one's usual horizons, going out and meeting people, giving yourself a break. Hard Truths teaches by example, in this respect.
It would be easy to imagine a film directed by a grumpy middle-aged Mancunian, on the lives of Black British characters, which fell somewhere between a condescending and reactionary disaster. Instead, Hard Truths emerges as a triumph, for reasons that hinge on the difference between filmmaker and central character. A model of entrenchment, Pansy struggles to change - but Leigh has changed, or at least allowed himself the possibility of some wiggle room through close, attentive collaboration. We should credit casting supremo Nina Gold with furnishing the director with these excellent, largely unfamiliar actors, but it's Leigh who's finally allowed them their head and given them their due. To highlight one example among many: note how Pansy's syntax sporadically slips from aggrieved South Londoner into something more Caribbean; to pursue a hairdressing pun her jolly sister might appreciate, her roots keep showing. Leigh may just have had the character down as someone who's fallen victim to a very British depression, but Jean-Baptiste inhabits Pansy and subtly delineates a woman in the throes of a full-on identity crisis: one who wasn't given much encouragement in her formative years, spent the bulk of her life being drained of all hope and purpose, and now finds herself with nowhere to go but back to bed. (One measurable achievement here: we get all this information from spending fewer than 97 minutes in her company.) Pansy isn't entirely beyond recovery and rehabilitation: she'd be much in demand as a commercial cleaner, for one, and would even make a brilliant, wounding critic. But she is, like a lot of things about modern Britain, messed-up and deeply complicated: increasingly, watching her, we don't know whether to laugh or cry. (She doesn't, either, if a climactic outpouring is anything to go by.) She is at her most heartbreaking in the film's closing moments, where collectively Leigh and Jean-Baptiste show us how hard it is for some people to try and live a normal life, to exert some agency over that life, when the pressures from outside are so great and you have this much baggage weighing down on your back. But that's where we all are in 2025, and that's why Leigh ends the film as he does: with a sitdown standoff between two crumpled figures in a whole heap of pain. They could conceivably support one another, hold each other up; equally, though, they could never speak again. The present tense of a Leigh film has rarely felt more present, nor more urgent, as Hard Truths comes to underline the one question no senior British statesman has yet managed to convincingly answer: where the hell do we go from here?
Hard Truths is now playing in selected cinemas.
