data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6aceb/6acebd7897582a0e564afee7e7cd5e28850a5468" alt=""
Narratively, it's slender, verging on the opaque - in this, it's badly served by the titles (and content) of the current UK DVD edition, for this is a film that needs context. There's a stand-off with neighboring rich farmers that leads to bloodshed, and a sense the old (workers and habits) will have to give way to the new - as one intertitle puts it (in caps, so we can't fail to spot it) "WE WILL PROSPER WITH MACHINES". More generally, however, industrialisation is handled with a lightness of touch: the direction and montage seeks to turn hard work - the cutting and collection of corn, the commercial-scale baking of bread - into a joyful dance, almost a celebration of labour, and of man's ability to work with the soil. It may just be a question of rhythm - that Eisenstein, working in the city, the engine room of the Revolution, was always likely to turn out something more mechanical than the lyricism Dovzhenko arrives at by removing himself to the countryside. Still, stretches of it rival Sunrise as the most purely beautiful work of cinema produced in this period, and cinephiles will see where Aleksandr Sokurov looks to have cribbed several of his best moves from, particularly in relation to death and slow-motion, and the bond that exists between mothers and sons.
Earth is available on DVD from Mr. Bongo Films.
No comments:
Post a Comment