The question is how this 21st century production goes about framing its raw material. We hear sporadically from Birrell's granddaughter Carina (a producer here), still picking over the circumstances of her own existence. Mostly, though, Films of Love and War unfolds in montage, with Birrell's images narrated by Richard Madden, reading from the filmmaker's diaries and letters home. What's striking about these is their plainness of expression: it's Birrell speaking directly to his emotions at any given point. The images, meanwhile, are speaking eloquently for themselves, and generating their own historical momentum. They'd do for any wartime melodrama Harry and his beloved Anne might have snuck away to see at the pictures: to see that, you need take only one look at the blues of the Indian Ocean soldier boy crossed to get to his eventual posting alongside the Gurkhas in Burma. The arterial scarlet spraying from the necks of those animals sacrificed during a welcoming ceremony would be as vivid, were Pinder not wise enough to tone down these images for a contemporary audience. As Carina wonders over images of corpses encountered on the battlefield: did Harry have a hand in these deaths? With the act of discovery comes the possibility of discovering something you might not like. (It was a simpler time, but also a less filtered time.) Nevertheless, taken as a whole, the Birrell films mesh into a captivating self-portrait of a young man testing himself and his limits, and making the camera a confidant in this process: shutter open, eyes wide. One quibble: this is 20th century footage subjected to 21st century editing rhythms, and you may find yourself - as I did - wanting certain images to linger a little more than they do, for whole reels to play out at their own pace. Even from these selected highlights, though, you gain a valuable understanding of a generation of working-class Brits who only got to travel because of the War - and of one man in particular, marvelling at the new frontiers opening up before him, the beauty and horror of it all. Harry Birrell really did sign up and see the world.
Harry Birrell Presents Films of Love and War is now streaming via the BBC iPlayer.
No comments:
Post a Comment